Social change: Hindus have higher rate of extreme poverty than Muslims in India now

Poverty rate among Hindus is higher than Muslims in India now, as overall extreme poverty rates have reduced in India.

Shams Ur Rehman Alavi

editor@asiantribune.net

Contrary to general perception, Muslims are no longer poorer than Hindus in India. Over the years, the poverty rates have been converging steadily in the country.

The poverty rate among Muslims has fallen below the Hindus. In rural India, Muslims are economically slightly more better off while in the urban India, the gap has closed down between the two major religions as the difference in poverty rate is barely 0.2%.

The data on the basis of the Household Consumption Expenditure Survey also corroborates it.

A decade ago it was not the same case. Though, the poverty is measured through different benchmarks but the trend that has led towards convergence is clear. Till 2012, the percentage of poverty among Muslims was higher than Hindus.

But now, there is a reversal. At national level, rate of extreme poverty among Muslims is 1.5% and for Hindus it is higher at 2.3%. That’s two decades after Sachar committee report.

The income household surveys also show that Muslim household income grew faster than Hindus between 2015-16 and 2022-23. The member of Economic Advisory Council to Prime Minister, Dr Shamika Ravi, has also stated in an interview that Muslims have a low poverty rate in rural India than Hindus, suggesting that the policies and welfare programs has helped all communities including the deprived groups, to moveahead, through inclusive growth.

The figures are from National Statistical Officer under the Ministry of Statistics and Program Implementation.

Arvind Panagariya and Vishal More’s research for Economic and Political Weekly last year had also said that extreme poverty across all communities, fell sharply in India.

Actually, till a couple of years ago, the national average showed that expenditure per household was quite close–Rs 4,455 for Muslims and 4,974 for Hindus. The key indicators are consumption, living standard, health access, assets

and though Muslims had a historical advantage due to their abysmal presence in Central and state government jobs or lesser presence in higher education, the gap between the two communities has come down in the last 15 years.

Tribal population is mostly in rural areas and they too were historically poorer but the extreme poverty has overall declined sharply in India. The baselines could be different for Rangarajan and Tendulkar but they point towards similar transition.

Across India, there are state-wise differences due to the sheer size and population of the country.  But, it is no longer possible to label entire community as ‘the poorer one’, because it is no longer the established fact and is not supported by figures.

Of course, TV channels, media and opinionated anchors or social conditioning and attitude towards minorities, is responsible for this generalization about Muslims.

Earlier, it was also observed that the literacy level among Muslims, particularly, the women of the community, had seen a rise.

In rural India, Muslim women have higher percent of literacy while gap narrows overall too.

Email: editor@asiantribune.net

Share via
Copy link